Angry Chinese Blogger

Angry Chinese Blogger: The news and views about China that the big media can't, or won't, tell you

The is no single truth

Menu
:
Home

China's ticking time bomb?

posted Sunday, 9 November 2008

When foreigners think of China they tend to think of it being a highly restricted country where state oppression means that public demonstrations are rare, and those that happen at all are orchestrated by the state against people whom it is acceptable to demonstrate against: the Japanese, for example.

However the truth is quite different. While it is true that China isn't known for the kind of  grass roots civil campaign that tend to spring up in countries like the US, it is also true that China is increasingly seeing mass demonstration the likes of which are rarely seen in the West. Demonstrations in which a sudden and explosive eruption of public anger can see hundreds, and often thousands, of people converging on symbols of authority or local corruption and practically tearing it apart with their bare hands. Indeed in one incident in 2007 alone almost 20,000 people battered Chinese security forces in Hunan province in response to a local incident, and there are few China watchers who haven't heard of the village of Dongzhou, and whom don't know what went on there, or why.

The Cause?


To the casual onlooker it is easy to say that these events, these mass disturbances or sudden eruptions of civil unrest, are usually caused by an act of corruption by local authorities or an act of brutality by local security forces: Somebody is badly beaten for complaining about a local businessman and the police do nothing, or maybe they were they ones who were doing the beating. A local leader confiscates some farmland land so that a factory can be build, pocketing a small fortune in bribes in the process but offers a pittance in compensation to displaced residence. Indeed, any of a 101 things that should have gone out with the feudal era, but which are rampant in post-Mao China.

However as any analyst or China watcher will tell you, it often pays to look deeper. Indeed, even a basic understanding of the modern Chinese people will tell you that everybody is so used to being dumped on from the top that you would be hard pressed to find a single act of corruption or a single violation of somebody else's rights that could get 200 Chinese out of bed, let alone get of Mainlanders 2000 to fight a running battle with security forces.

When you get right down to it, and you finally look to the roots of China's unrest you will often find that the event over which people are protesting is merely a match dropped on a long trail of gunpowder that leading up to the powder keg that is unrest.

Powder keg?

One key denominator in the above determination is the people whom are usually found on the front line of the unrest. Or, to be more specific, their demographic. By and large, the people whom make up the core of any significant incident of unrest in China are usually rural or provincial poor. Farmers, residents of satellite townships, and so on. In short, People whom make a living but little more, and whose main interest in life is to get by for one more day.

As a group such people whom have been largely left out of the bright side of China's economic boom, but they still suffer from the many aspects of its dark side. Such as official corruption, pollution, and higher food prices. This state of affairs has created a general undercurrent of anger and resentment that remains simmering beneath the surface of China's population, rarely coming to a head. Except of course when the right trigger even come along and hits home with the right number of people in the right place, at the right time. BANG a long suffering group of people explode into unrest. 

A Gathering Storm?

Of course, all that was said above is said in regards to the China of yesterday. Maybe 1998 though early 2008, if that. From where ACB is standing China's problems with civil unrest look set to become much worse.

Why is this, you may ask? Well, the reason is simple. Up until now the main players in China's unrest have been the rural and provincial poor. Nameless, faceless people with few expectations in life whom have become so used being downtrodden and marginalized that it takes a long time for the pressure to build up to an explosive appex. However, with the world economy going south, new players look set to join the mix. People whom had hopes and dreams of a better life in a new China. People whom are now finding that the opportunities that were gradually opening up to them are now closing fast. These people look set to be even more volotile. Parlty because they have had their hopes dashed, and partly because they have not been tempered to expect so little out of life as the rural poor have in the first place. Their anger will rise faster and it will rise further.

Things to Come?

ACB predicts that if things continue the way that they are China is going to see increasing numbers of riots by workers whom wake up one day to find that their bosses have vanished, along with their payroles, and increased incidents of unrest caused by migrant workers who simply cannot face the prospect of returning home without the fortunes that they left to seek. ACB can also see an increasing backlash coming against schools and colleges as both student and parent come to realize that the marvelous prospects that they were promised are fast sinking as economic growth in China slows, and as economic growth around the world stalls.

Some of this is evident already, but how much worse it gets remains to be seen. One thing is certain though, that the heavier the hand of government is with these people, the more likely they are to explode.

The clock is ticking. It was ticking when China's rural poor started to rise up against pollution and illegal land seizures, and it was ticking when  workers started demanding more rights. Now, however, it is ticking with increasing urgency, and the echo in being heard in the wealthier cities and towns of China's South and east coasts.

links: digg this    del.icio.us    technorati    reddit




1. dave zimmerman left...
Sunday, 9 November 2008 8:45 am

WOW!


2. PotatoChef left...
Sunday, 9 November 2008 1:52 pm :: http://www.PotatoPatchRecipes.com

You make a good point. Like in any other country the middle class can get pretty angry when they feel that they are about to lose everything they have worked for. In China the middle class has been getting bigger by the day, which means there will be a lot of angry people as the economy gets worse and worse.

Of course the bright spot to all of this is that the government in China will probably see it as beneficial to keep the USA and Europe happy with them as to not disrupt trade.


3. Job left...
Sunday, 9 November 2008 3:10 pm

Nobody cares when a few of the proles get angry, but you start having real problems when discontent starts seeping into the Outer Party. ;D


4. ACB left...
Sunday, 9 November 2008 6:59 pm

Job

Since about 80% of the Chinese population consists of "proles" or below, Beijing is actually rather concerned about them. To date the vast majority of unrest has been amongst the working poor. It is not unknown for there to be incidents of unrest involving 5000 or more "proles", in some cases 10-20,000. Over the last few years there have been maybe half a dozen incidents approaching the scale of the Watts riots.

What Beijing is going ot have to watch is that unrest in China may move out of the satellite villages and township and into more densely populated areas. I think that the biggest fear is of an explosion of anger amongst people who are aspiring middle class. There are a lot of them, they haven't been tempered by a lifetime of having nothing, and they have hopes and dreams that they don't want to loose. Such people made up a large slice of those involved in the Anti-Japanese Riots.


5. Job left...
Wednesday, 12 November 2008 12:33 am

Uh, precisely. Hm, that's pretty much what I said, although with a snarkier tone. Peasants in the countryside have been rioting for a while now. The fact that some have had 5000 to 10,000 to 20,000 participants actually underscores my point. It's a phenomenon that the Party has been gaining more and more experience dealing with. Hence, nobody cares when a few proles get angry. Because 20,000 is a few - when you understand that none of these are becoming coordinated regional or even national movements among China's vast underclass. And while there are party apparatuses that do care and whose purpose is to resolve these issues, the people who matter more to the ruling class - the rising, hopeful newly educated middle class and the people who are almost there - really didn't care about what a bunch of farmers evicted from their land were rioting about, what with their new SUVs and ipods. These folks didn't mobilize to support the farmers and countryside peasants. Not yet anyways.

You mention that 80% of China's population is underclass, my reference to 1984 is intentional (and tongue in cheek, by the way! If you didn't notice). 85% of Oceania are proles! But it's the outer party that needs to be controlled more. As numerous as the proles are, their mass is nothing without a few more magic ingredients.

We recall the one major nationwide outbreak of unrest in the modern history of the party, that occurred when an alliance was made between a young, energized, educated "new middle class" who provided a face and a rallying point for the unrest and poorer members of the lower class. That's what you're mentioning in your post. Correctly. "What Beijing is going to have to watch." The point of your whole post is that something is different is coming, something more alarming. That the unrest has the potential to seep into the better off individuals and those enamored with the possibility of moving up indicates a more lethal and dangerous tone to the general unrest in China that has been continuing for years, mostly among the underclass. I totally agree with you. Completely. It was far less lethal without this new element. The party has established it can deal with angry peasants and migrant workers. It's got a pretty good track record (or bad depending on how you look at it haha). However, angry peasants and migrant workers mixed with students and young professionals (people I snidely dub the outer party) might be a little to reminiscent of some previous icky thing that didn't turn out to well.

But I know I annoy you as a commenter on your blog so it's on your agenda to wag a finger at whatever snarky comment I toss into the mix. But really! I was just putting a little literary allusion to what you were saying. It's good stuff. Rock on, ACB! This needs to be heard.<3<3


6. ron753 left...
Wednesday, 3 December 2008 6:22 pm

I have just found your blog today, and it is very interesting to read news from someone living in China. I'll be returning to your blog regularly.