Anybody who knows anything about totalitarian regimes be they real regimes such as those found in Soviet Russia, fictional regimes such as found in George Orwell's 1984 will probably be aware of the term "Re-Education".
Usually, re-education is synonymous with the term "Brainwashing", and the two are often used interchangeable with the former being used where the latter is not politically acceptable, and the latter being used where that which is being so named goes beyond techniques of propaganda and controlled ignorance that all too many states seem to rely on these days to direct the opinions of masses.
In some instances the characterization of re-education, or any other hearts and minds campaign for that matter, as being brainwashing is somewhat unfair and purjorative. However, As far as China's treatment of Tibetans and Tibetan culture are concerned, it is fully justified. Worse still, it is also set to increase.
From the pen of journalist and China watcher Karl Malakuna:
Do not get this blogger wrong, ACB deeply loves China but Beijing's behavior in Tibet, however, is an abhorrence the likes of which this blogger does not have the vocabulary to express as it should be expressed. It is nothing less than cultural genocide. An effort to take Tibet out of the Tibetan people and to replace it with the Han culture, and not even true Han but rather neutered, sanitized, secularized post Mao Han culture.
Tibet should be for the Tibetans, Beijing has no business being there and no business doing what it is doing.
The term "Re-Education" sends shivers down my back. The Chinese need to
stop this non-sense and move into the 21st century. The world needs to
boycott the olympics so that China knows without a doubt that what it is
doing in Tibet is not acceptable.
Only those who were on the spot can tell the truth about Tibet.
I can't judge merely by what you said or what the Chinese government said.
June, I could put you in touch with a number of groups who could show you
the testemonies of many Tibetans and Tibetan exiles if you like.
What's funny is that while you guys are talking about the "horrible" fact
about "re-educated", you are being re-educated just by the irresponsible
report from your media. Tibet is just one part of China, just as Ireland in
UK, or LA in USA, it's none of other country's business.
Ashley:
to ACB:
why don't you point out your issue more clearly?
if you mean race problem, the obvious fact is that in China nobody will
treat you differently according to your race.
My classmates are from differnt races, and one of my friends is just a girl
from Tibet. The so-called genocide matter never puzzled her, 'cause there
is no such things around her true life.
I understand why somebody want to get separated, or "free". Man with full
ambition always wants to be his own king, and guess what, if Tibet became a
indepent country, next "free" country will be...Ireland?
They are living a peaceful life, just as everybody else in this country.
Yes, some people may be rich, some maybe poor, that is just happening
everywhere in every country. Completely justice? Never exist. But here we
are, doing our best to develop our country, hunting jobs, making a living,
and, peaceful life.
We all need that peace, right?
No goverment is perfect, even yours. But in human right issue, we are doing
the same as your goverment. Somebody wants to seperate our country and fire
the war, bring it on. We are standing togethor, me, the Tibet girl ,and
many many people here.
Ashley:
to ACB:
er...Excuse me, have you been to China?
The only reason my Tibet girl friend doesn't wear her tradition clothes is
that it is not as fation as what a teenage wears everyday.
What about native Americans? Do they always wear tradiytion clothers in
daily life?
In tradition customs, people wears traditional clothes in their holidays,
and that is a normal thing in China. It is respected.
and... last question, honestly, have you been to China, once?
'Cause I am now linving in Beijing, if you come here someday, maybe I can
be your guide.