When he's appointed by the Chinese government. Seriously, this isn't made up.
Care of Reuters
This reads very much like something out of Mao's time. Then, as now, You have to ask yourself 2 questions:
1) What on Earth does China's secular Han government known about the true reincarnations of Tibetan Lama?
2) By what right does Beijing do this?
This is among the most blatant interferences in religious affairs that this blogger has seen in a good long while. Even if you do not believe in reincarnation, and even if you don't give a hoot about the desecration of Tibetan culture; which is entirely your right, you have to feel sorry for the poor children that Beijing will choose as "true" reincarnations. They will be taken from the world, kept as virtual prisoner and forcefully "educated" in the ways of Han - As was done with the Beijing's candidate for the 11th Panchan Lama - without regard to their feelings or rights.
Let China control everything and anything IN China... Same thing as the
U.S. is trying to control everything it can in the world or at least have
an influence on it. So called American Interests.
I agree that the Chinese government's actions in Tibet are deplorable on a
range of levels - and most especially on freedom of religion, freedom of
assembly and freedom of expression. However, your point about the
indoctrination and isolation of the government appointed lamas needs a bit
of qualification. Remember that if there was freedom of religion the
children annointed lamas by the Tibetan clergy would still be taken away
and subject to a pretty fierce form of indoctrination and isolation. Of
course if one believes they really are the reincarnation of a centuries old
religious leader then that's perfectly acceptable, but...
"Let China control everything and anything IN China..."
'Duncan' , just to be clear, the "indoctrination" that would be given to a
young Lama is rather different from that which would be given to a Beijing
appointee. For starters, they are not being programmed to destroy their own
culture like some kind of sleeper agent.